Germany
In
Germany, trafficking in human beings constitutes a specific
criminal offence. However, the definition the law gives of
this practice is limited to the exploitation of another person's
prostitution and does not take into account any form of economic
exploitation.
The
notion of 'economic slavery' is reduced to a breach of
German labour laws. Indeed, only the labour laws sanction the
exploitation of foreigners through work.
The
notion of 'trafficking in human beings for the purpose of
sexual exploitation' is defined in Germany's criminal code.
Article
180b, which addresses the issue of trafficking in human beings,
sanctions the inducing or forcing of a person into prostituting
him or herself by taking advantage of vulnerabilities or difficulties
caused by his or her presence in a foreign country.
Article
181 defines serious trafficking in the following terms: first,
as the inducing or forcing of an individual to prostitute him
or herself; and secondly, as the engaging of an individual
for the purposes of prostitution either by taking advantage
of this person's vulnerability or through the use of force,
violence, or any other form of fraudulent behaviour.
Other
articles of the criminal code condemn situations inherent in
trafficking conducted for the purpose of sexual exploitation,
such as the exploitation of prostitution (article 180a), acting
as a pimp (article 181a), abduction (article 177), sexual coercion
(article 178), sexual abuse of a person incapable of self-defence
(article 179), or the exploitation of child prostitution (article
180).
The
German government considers the problem of trafficking in human
beings as part of the fight against organised crime and illegal
immigration. In principle, any immigrant judged to be illegal,
including victims of trafficking, is deported. However, victims
of trafficking are not systematically prosecuted, especially
if they agree to co-operate with the courts.
In
certain Lander, internal administrative texts allow victims
four weeks to leave Germany. During this period, known as the
Duldung, victims can decide either to make preparations
for their departure or to lodge a complaint. If after four weeks
they are still present in the country without having lodged
a complaint, they are deported.
The
lodging of a complaint authorises victims to stay in the country
during the course of the ensuing legal proceedings (article
5 of the law concerning the residence of foreigners in Germany).
But this authorisation does not take the form of an official
residence permit; rather, it amounts to a postponement of deportation
in the general public interest. Such a deferment depends upon
the usefulness of the victim as a witness in the legal enquiry.
Victims do not acquire the right to work, and nor are they eligible
to receive assistance provided for by a federal law regulating
social benefits. Such benefits can only be granted to victims
by a law providing aid to asylum seekers, a social assistance
package that is 20-25% less than that handed out under federal
law.
Once
a judgement has been made, victims must leave Germany. Article
54 of the law concerning the residence of foreigners provides
for the granting of a permanent residence permit if it is judged
that the victim/witness would risk his or her life by returning
home. But this type of permit is only granted in a very few
cases.
As
a result of this situation, many victims simply disappear and
live a clandestine life either in Germany or in another country
that has signed the Schengen agreement. Others attempt to marry
in order to stay on legally in Germany. However, a permanent
residence permit is only granted after four years of marriage.
And circumstances such as these undoubtedly make the victim
vulnerable.
Certain
Lander have set up special commissions to address the
problems related to trafficking in human beings (Fachkommisssion
Frauenhandel). These bodies bring together NGOs along with
members of the police force, the legal authorities and social
services departments. Their objectives are to co-ordinate activities
related to problems of trafficking in women and to make recommendations
to the government.
When
a victim files a complaint and when the police judge that the
victim is actually in danger, she may choose to take advantage
of a protection programme. In Germany, victim assistance and
protection is provided by social centres.